Monday, March 24, 2014

Professional Journal Analysis

Library Journal

The Library Journal is a peer reviewed professional publication. They publish a magazine, newsletter, webcasts, website, and blogs of interests to academic, public, and specialty librarians. They review books, publish articles and webcasts on topics such as current trends in libraries, notable librarians, and various opinions of the profession written by those currently in it. Their website offers a “Career Zone” where a career in the library profession can be researched, and job opportunities can be posted. Of all the publications I am required to read for my job, The Library Journal is my favorite.  I enjoy learning about what other libraries are doing. I find the articles inspirational and have taken note on several ideas that I have translated into something we could do at my library. My favorite feature is the “Pre Pub Alert.” As a materials selector, I have the “Pre Pub Alert” section of The Library Journal out as I order. I find this publication to be a great tool.

 The American Archivist

The American Archivist is a peer reviewed professional publication as well.  They publish a journal, newsletter, brochures, and several free publications intended for archival professionals and those interested in the field. They publish articles and information on topics of current trends, notable persons in the profession, and review books related to the archive profession. As a public librarian in a small community, this publication is not one I would not necessarily subscribe to. I do see the value in knowing about it, and perhaps reading some of the articles every so often. Archives are important to researchers, which the public library does serve, and I could see how knowing archival methods and resources would be of use.

Notable Comparisons

Both of these publications are peer reviewed. Peer review is important because it helps to, “maintain standards of quality, improve performance, and provide credibility” (Peer Review, n.d.). They both offer several different publications, although The Library Journal offers more, such as webcasts and blogs. I believe both of these publications would be of interest to those in the library and information profession, even if their careers are outside of the intended audience.


From reviewing these publications, I have come to realize how important these and similar publications are to the library and information profession.  The availability of these journals help keep those that are no longer in school informed on current trends. They allow for librarians and information professionals to learn from each other, and take what others are doing and implement these ideas in their own careers. These publications are incredibly important to keeping the profession moving forward.

References

The American Archivist. (n.d.). Society of American Archivists. Retrieved March 24, 2014, from http://www2.archivists.org/american-archivist

Library Journal. (n.d.). Library Journal. Retrieved March 24, 2014, from http://lj.libraryjournal.com/

Peer Review. (n.d.).Wikipedia. Retrieved March 24, 2014, from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peer_review

No comments:

Post a Comment